Can't decide which MPC to choose? Read these resources or post your questions here.
By J_Mayer Mon Sep 29, 2008 8:14 am
Hey all, been a recent lurker on the forum, but finally choosing to weigh in.
(I'll have a pic of me in front of the MPC5000 up soon so as to squelch any identity issues)

I've gotten way into the MPC lately, and I've been able to take a bit of both my own experience and what I've read on the boards and I'd like to share some perspective.

I've owned through the years every incarnation of MPC since a 2000xl, but I never had the focus to dig in on it until a few months ago. I've been consumed by the 5000 ever since I bought it.

Here are some things I want to send up the flagpole and see if they don't help a few people out. (I'm also looking forward to getting advice on some issues as they come up for me as a user.)

*The MPC is a powerful and dangerous machine; powerful because it has the potential to produce some amazing MUSIC, but dangerous in that the act of creation can be so confusingly satisfying that you might not realize you're not really creating music. Building programs, constantly loading in as many samples as you can find, etc. are all great things to build an arsenal of sounds, but it can be very difficult to get to the actual production stage. I battle that all the time. It's better to play a bonehead 2 bar kick-snare-hat beat that you record a song around than to spend an afternoon trying to sync MIDI up with another sound module just to say you did it. One is creation and one is just activity for activity's sake. So with that said, I've only gone so far as to use the MPC to come up with beats and the occasional melodic sample. But I'm good enough on it to have already used it on the upcoming album. The thing is just fun to use.

I also want to say that I understand exactly why someone would want a 3000 or a 60, or even a 2000. Because it's romantic. I want to work on the same machine Pete Rock made all those great tracks on, but the fact is you can do it on any of the MPCs, and what people mean by "swing" isn't so much about the timing of the groove but the way it feels to use the machine as far as touch and sight goes. And that's important. If looking at yourself using the limited edition 3000 makes you feel like a badass and that makes you play something cool, then you did get a different swing out of it.

*MPC5000 gripes: I've read a ton of complaints about the 5000, but in general it's a great machine. They ALL are. To anybody trying to figure out which one to buy, remember that they all go "chick-chick-boom" with either sounds you recorded yourself or sounds that someone else recorded. I'm using the MPC in a professional setting, but admittedly rather lightly in terms of using every feature. So my thoughts are always going to reflect that.

The biggest problem with the 5000 is the interface on the TRIM feature. It's WAY too numeric for me, and the constant shifting of the "tens place" as a poor man's ZOOM + and ZOOM - feature is tough to work with, especially when hitting the WINDOW button returns your sample change intervals to 1. It's a lot of shift-clicking.

THE JJ OS 2 on the MPC 1000 has this LICKED, with a fluid jog wheel and zoom features that make all the sense in the world. I was cutting samples up faster than i believe I ever could on a DAW.

The jog wheel on the MPC 5000 is pretty bad. (Sorry AKAI people.) It feels hollow, and actually fails to deliver on the basic fundamental principles of wheel-iness. Go into the effects mixer and you'll go mad trying to set each pad to "1". It's an average of about 2-3 clicks for every one increment change. That's tough to get over.

BUT, it's got a ton of power. There's no worry about RAM restrictions, and I'm actually inspired by the size of the internal HD. I like the idea of traveling from studio to studio with a world of music inside it. Which leads me to another thought:

File hierarchy on all MPCs have always been crummy, but for reasons I don't understand, the 5000 seems even worse. I'm starting to believe the only way I can make sense of my files is to keep a mac connected through USB and mount the MPC every couple of hours to organize through the desktop on OSX. There is also a huge bug in terms of extracting samples and file naming. I won't get into it now, but the naming and numerating of the samples goes haywire. Imagine wanting to make a program of tambourines and having TAMB, TAMB1 and TAMB 001 stand for 3 different samples. It's got to get smarter in terms of assisting in naming and organizing samples.

MPC 5000 awesomeness: button layout. Feels great to me. I can work around it very fast. Even though I have a feeling any MPC you use can get comfortable.

So check it out: All I want to do on an MPC is play drums on it, be able to record and cut samples, and be able to recall my saved files with relative ease. Guess what? The MPC 1000 with the JJ OS2 becomes the perfect machine. Once I get the memory expansion, that is. I'd like to know if the pre-amps are any better on the more expensive MPCs, because if not, I'm going to become a full-time 1000 user. Everything is more intuitive. I know it sound corny but it's true: less time futzing wit electronics means more time laying music down. And for me, 1000 seems like the machine to go with. I'll never need a synth inside the MPC and I'll always use a DAW to record real-time audio.


I'm excited to trade/share ideas on this board and I'm looking forward to getting super knowledgeable on the MPC...


John
User avatar
By DukeNewport Mon Sep 29, 2008 11:30 am
By identity issue - R u implying it's not really him? (He wouldn't be the first successful musician to post here)

I wasn't sure, so I googled John Mayer. Turns out John Mayer posts on his blog pretty often...and they sound just like the entry above.
User avatar

By Lampdog Mon Sep 29, 2008 11:41 am
J_Mayer wrote:Hey all, been a recent lurker on the forum, but finally choosing to weigh in.


Welcome and a great first post big dog.
User avatar
By Dodgedriver82 Mon Sep 29, 2008 12:52 pm
im not implyin that its not him (if it is, thats kick ass, i enjoy dudes material ) , im just sayin, reguardless of who it is, i really liked that post .
By xibalba1875 Mon Sep 29, 2008 1:21 pm
Wrong choice on the 5000 :D but all jokes aside. Welcome to the mpc fam. Im sure you will find that a lot of us are a knowledgeable lot....... :D

wilkkomen and bienvenue!
By dtaa pla muk Mon Sep 29, 2008 2:22 pm
glad you're digging jjos2 - i had no idea you were into MPCs, i guess i am not too familiar with your music. my biggest memory is of seven years ago or so, when the girl i was dating kept playing a recording of you beatboxing at a concert - she was very much infatuated with you (thanks a lot, jerk)

in all seriousness, maybe you have/haven't seen these videos, but you might dig them. they're some jjos2 tutorial videos i put together of some tricks that i like to use.

http://youtube.com/nymantics
User avatar

Re:

By konc3pt Mon Sep 29, 2008 8:51 pm
Lampdog wrote:
J_Mayer wrote:Hey all, been a recent lurker on the forum, but finally choosing to weigh in.


Welcome and a great first post big dog.
By J_Mayer Mon Sep 29, 2008 9:29 pm
Nym, I like the videos. Gonna refer to it as time goes on... BTW, what did you do to your 1000? Are you making beats on the ship in the Matrix??

JM
By J_Mayer Mon Sep 29, 2008 9:31 pm
And by the way, has anyone here ever thought of building a dedicated rack just for the output of the MPC? I'm thinking about getting a 4U rack space and finding two great preamps/compressors so that the drums always have a signature sound... It would be cool to have the MPC perched up on top of one or two mastering-quality units...
Overkill, maybe...
By dtaa pla muk Mon Sep 29, 2008 10:23 pm
i sanded off the paint/lettering and let rust form under a clearcoat/replaced the green lcd with a blue one. it looks like after the end of the human species.

regarding a dedicated output mastering box, a lot of us use DAWs in that way, but more in a "tracking out" sense rather than mastering before recording. i did buy an extra delta66 (4 input, 4 output, spdif I/O) to use the inputs specifically for the 1000
User avatar
By temetrepo Tue Sep 30, 2008 12:05 am
J_Mayer wrote:And by the way, has anyone here ever thought of building a dedicated rack just for the output of the MPC? I'm thinking about getting a 4U rack space and finding two great preamps/compressors so that the drums always have a signature sound... It would be cool to have the MPC perched up on top of one or two mastering-quality units...
Overkill, maybe...


that would be dope, but a lot of us in here don't have that loot right now to get that kind of gear
but we all can dream right :mrgreen: