MPC5000 reviews, bug reports and fellow user support on the most recent standalone, hardware MPC from Akai
By Cat3 Sun Dec 19, 2010 2:04 pm
hi guys,

I have a weird problem with my mpc 5000. I'm making a song in 5/4 time signature. I've made about 10 sequences all in 5/4 and all was working fine until I saved the project (save entire memory content).

when I reload the project the sequences' time signature is no more 2 bars in 5/4 but the first in 5/4 and the second in 3/4.

if I open the time signature window and close it (do it) the sequence plays ok again (5/4 + 5/4) but the problem repeats for all the sequences... this means that if I make a song made of say 30 sequences, every time I reload the project I have to pass through all the 30 sequences and change the time signature of EACH of them to make them play in the correct time signature.

I've tried to begin a new project from scratch in 5/4 and the result is the same, so it's not a project-related problem.

anyone of you had this problem? is there a way to solve it?

thanks in advance.
By philipp Sun Dec 19, 2010 10:00 pm
I can reproduce the problem on my machine as well. Even storing the sequence with "SAVE A SEQUENCE" or with "SAVE ALL SEQS AND SONGS" leads to the problem, that the time signature 5/4 is being displayed after loading but not executed.
By Cat3 Mon Dec 20, 2010 9:48 am
many thanks for checking philipp!

I'm currently into IDM music production and this is a really serious problem, as odd time signatures are used all the time in this genre...

anyone knows how this can be solved?

ps: you know what's funny? I also have NI maschine and it also presents weird bugs when in 5/4 signature... :(

pps: c'mon AKAI stop playing with that stupid plastic usb controllers and dedicate some effort fixing the OS of a machine like the 5000 that could be THE BOMB with the right updates!!! and please note my mpc costs like TEN of these stupid controllers!!!
By ghosty Fri Dec 24, 2010 9:25 am
Its not the OS. Did you try saving each program related to each sequence also? Like seq1INTRO - and INTRO as program with you time signature then loading all the sequences into song.mode?
By lobster Fri Dec 24, 2010 7:25 pm
Hi Cat3,

I encountered the same problem when I was working on a complete concert setup on my 5k. Odd time signatures (7/4 and 5/4 in my case) didn't load correctly after saving the project (all). I had to reassign the time signature to the sequence and then it worked again, as far as I remember. It's definitely a problem of the OS like many others. I guess that 99 percent of the mpc users are using a 4/4 time signature and never ever stumbled about this ... as well as the developers!

As far as I'm concerned I told three different akai representatives about this and other obvious bugs. I mailed complete and reproducable descriptions of bugs to akai and the developer team. No update, not even an answer, just ignorance! Akai is either unable or unwilling to fix the machine. It's a shame anyway.

So Akai, go ahead concentrating on toys like those iPhone apps and mini usb keyboards and get lost in irrelevance.
By Cat3 Tue Dec 28, 2010 11:08 am
lobster wrote:As far as I'm concerned I told three different akai representatives about this and other obvious bugs. I mailed complete and reproducable descriptions of bugs to akai and the developer team. No update, not even an answer, just ignorance! Akai is either unable or unwilling to fix the machine. It's a shame anyway.


they just don't care... this is how a toy like NI's Maschine will defeat the sacred monster...
By Sovereign Thu Mar 10, 2011 12:14 pm
Cat3 wrote:
lobster wrote:As far as I'm concerned I told three different akai representatives about this and other obvious bugs. I mailed complete and reproducable descriptions of bugs to akai and the developer team. No update, not even an answer, just ignorance! Akai is either unable or unwilling to fix the machine. It's a shame anyway.


they just don't care... this is how a toy like NI's Maschine will defeat the sacred monster...



Maschine is far from a toy.
The problem with the 5k and odd time signatures comes from Akai implementing non-destructive bar editing.
Basically it gives the 5k sequencer a false/confused reference linked to the bars, their T/S and loop point.
They should just remove the feature and make the 5k work like older MPs.
By ant grallen Fri Dec 21, 2012 11:34 pm
yo, first time posting here. recently grabbed a 5000 cuz the price was nice due to it being discontinued. it took only a few days for me to stumble onto the "time signature bug." it is unfortunate (and embarrassing for AkaiPro) that this "flagship" model can't handle saving sequences made outside of 4/4. BUT..no use in bitching more about it.

I assume that the members on this thread have a solid sense of rhythm and odd meters since it seems to be what we are striving for with this machine. SO..you all may have all ready figured this workaround for yourselves. I searched the site and have not seen it posted yet, so I figured I put in my two cents. here's how it works:

let's say that you want to make a sequence in 6/4 with the ability to save it and recall it perfectly. this IS possible on the MPC 5000, but the method is slightly roundabout (it doesn't take all that long, probably 2-4 more minutes of work to set up).

instead of changing our time signature, we will leave it set at 4/4 (since this seems to be the source of the problem). we are going to focus instead on the bar length of the sequence. in this example, we want a 6/4 pattern, so we will set the bar length to 3. this will give us 3 bars, each containing 4 quarter notes. that is a total of 12 beats in the entire sequence (3x4). if we treat the whole sequence as 1 bar, then our time signature becomes 12/4. now we just break it down into smaller parts. 1 bar @ 12/4 = 2 bars @ 6/4. both expressions contain the same 12 beats. so now we have 2 bars of 6/4. however, our click track is still set to 4/4, so if we hit record, it will still sound like 3 bars @ 4/4, not 2 bars @6/4. to fix this we have to make our own click track.

choose an unused track, and choose two pads (one to be the straight quarter note beat, and one to be the click accent signaling the '1' of every bar). record a straight quarter note beat for the whole sequence using the first sound, and then turn of the metronome. now we should only here 12 quarter notes with no accent straight through the whole sequence. go into overdub and record the click accents on the '1' of every bar. in this case, we have 2 bars of 6/4, so we will have 2 click accents on the 1st and 7th beat of the entire sequence. now play that back, and you have 2 bars set at 6/4 with a sexy click track ready to go!.....so go!! bang out your beat, fine tune it, whatever, all in 6/4!...nice 8)

save it and recall it perfectly. just remember to either mute or erase your click track when you are finished with your beat.

do this for all other time signatures:

for 5/4: set your bar length to 5 (remember, always keep the ACTUAL time signature of the MPC at 4/4). that gives us 1 bar @ 20/4 = 2 bars @ 10/ 4 = 4 bars @ 5/4

for 7/4: set your bar length to 7. that gives us 1 bar @ 28/4 = 2 bars @ 14/ 4 = 4 bars @ 7/4

see the pattern here? however many beats you want in one bar (i.e. 7) will be what you set the sequence length to (i.e. 7 bars) WITHOUT EVER ACTUALLY COMING OUT OF 4/4. for all the 5000 knows, you are always playing in 4/4, and that's just groovy.

*note: for 3/4, you just take the first example of 6/4 and break it down one more step. 2 bars @ 6/4 = 4 bars @ 3/4

don't forget that you will have to record your own click track for all of these changes!

and that's it...
save these bad boys with no problems, and recall them flawlessly.

LIMITATIONS:
:shock:
as you can see from my examples, while we can trick the 5000 into saving sequences in odd time signatures, those sequences will always have the same # of bars in them. i.e. if I write something in 5/4 using this method, that sequence MUST be 4 bars long. so, you will not be able to make a 5/4 sequence that is 3 or 5 bars long, etc.

however, there is another little trick. i have found that if you change the time signature for the sequence (actually change it in the MPC, not use this workaround) and save it WITH THE LOOP SWITCH TURNED OFF, then it will load up properly, and play through the sequence exactly one time (as it should). it seems that looping in odd time signatures is what gives it trouble.
SO.....you can use these two tricks together.

example:
1. make a beat in sequence 001 in 7/4 using the method stated above (this will give you 4 bars of 7/4). set the loop to ON.

2. make a beat in sequence 002 in 5/4 by actually changing the time signature and set the bars length to 3 (or 1, or whatever). set the loop to OFF.

3. string them together in song mode. play sequence 001 two times through, and then switch to sequence 002 once, and go back to sequence 001. (or whatever, it's all up to you!)

save yo shiz, recall yo shiz, play yo shiz again and again. sexy. :wink:

let me know if this is helpful, or if anyone even sees this, as it is an old thread.
glad to be here!