
It really depends on the type of AD/DA converters in the machines which makes a difference, soundwise.
If you have descent components every step of the chain, meaning : descent source material, descent preamps, descent cables, descent recording medium .. etc.. you will most likely get a descent sound .
If one component is not so good it can mess up your whole chain...
But really, it's all about vibe and WORKFLOW .
Whatever works for you, you should stick with. Don't get caught up in gear, techniques etc... in the end it's all about what works well for you.
Of course it's sensible to get proper knowledge and gear, but that's relative to workflow again.
Example : you can have all the nicest preamps , console, converters, musicians, cables, microphones etc..
But a small thing like lighting or smell can mess up the vibe for the musicians and they will not perform well, ending in a well recorded sheiss.... just something to think about..
Same goes for your setup, you can have a maxed out mpc 4000 with a octo-core mac computer loaded with all the software ever created, running a SSL 9000 going through some apogee rosetta's converters .... but still, if you can't work in that environment it's not going to happen musically....