CharlesRandolph wrote:1. People have access to a library. In a library there are books. Some of those books are about music theory and sound engineering. Grab them, read them, and apply them.
Why would they do that? They had the talent and the drive. No one said they were "wanting" for anything, in terms of knowledge or talent. I take this to mean you look down on vital music they made. I'm not surprised.
CharlesRandolph wrote:2. If hip hopper had samplers, speakers, records, and turntables. That meant there was some kind of music store right? People work there, right? Ask them question. Knowledge is not given it must be searched for.
Again.... why? Why do you continually keep suggesting that they weren't good enough, Charles?
CharlesRandolph wrote:3. The Youth could've gone to a place called church. Were they could learn to sing and play instruments. That's where Aretha Franklin, James Brown, Miles Davis, Sallie Martin, Quincy Jones, Albertina Walker, Thomas A Dorsey, learned music.. I could go on.
...and on. And on. And ON.
Why should they have done that? They took what they had and created the most popular music format on earth. If they went to church and learned to play traditional instruments, we wouldn't have hip hop. Something tells me that'd suit you fine... You don't respect it. That much is obvious. Which is likely why you don't respect "toys". But your in a forum for a sampler. MPC has a deep tradition in hip hop. Guys like Premier and Doom and JD and Pete Rock and Madlib and Lord Finesse and Ced Gee and Q-Tip... these guys handle an MPC with the skill and dexterity of a great musician. It IS their instrument.
In fact, Guru's "Jazzmatazz" series kinda proves that live instrumentation in hip hop kinda falls flat, when compared to a great sample-based producer's music. No matter how funky they get; no mater what giants of traditional jazz musicianship they put in one room, they really couldn't achieve the same raw power as a guy like Preem delivered with a turntable and an MPC.
CharlesRandolph wrote:I can write BATTLE raps all day long, big deal! It's easy to tear someone down.
Again, you devalue the art of hip hop. "I can do (this and that) all day long" is the same bullshit that all Luddites throughout history say. Yet they never really can. You can do it all day long? Sure you can...