WD Blue SATA SSD Drive Mounting Issue

I have a Western Digital Blue 250gig SATA SSD hard drive connected to my MPC Live. It shows up in Live correctly, but when I connect Live to my Windows PC via USB, I get multiple errors. A window for the drive will pop up, but then will disappear, saying the drive could not be accessed. Windows also tells me the drive has issues and needs ‘repair’, but when I try to ‘repair’ it, it basically freezes.

I am using the latest firmware version. The drive is recently formatted exFAT.

The 32gig flash drive inserted into Live mounts just fine on my PC. Anyone run into this? Thanks in advance!