By giacecco
Sat Feb 24, 2024 10:47 am
Mmmhh it is not possible that I am starting this thread, but I could find only the bug reports thread for 2.11-12. This was also reported to Akai.
Despite Monitor button set to off, external MIDI source disrupts playback. This was observed on MPC-X standalone running firmware 2.13.0. To reproduce:
1) Configure a MIDI track to receive notes using MIDI DIN from an external sequencer. Make the sequence receive and use the MPC's clock, start and stop. Record a sequence made of rich chords, e.g. 5 notes at a time.
2) Set the Monitor button from Auto to Off.
3) On the external sequencer, change its configuration to play something else, but so that it still starts and stops together with the MPC.
4) Playback the sequence, and you will hear that a few notes in the chord seem to be disrupted: they don't start at all, or get a Note Off sooner than the others in the same chord. For safety, monitor what is played by using a MIDI visualizer (e.g. see https://imgur.com/eXZkxCa ).
5) Set MIDI INPUT to <none>, and the sequence will playback correctly instead.
But shouldn't the Monitor button set to off be sufficient not to be disrupted by the external sequencer? The user guide version 2.13 on page 147 says that "When set to Off, the track's MIDI input is not monitored, and playback of recorded events will be heard".
Despite Monitor button set to off, external MIDI source disrupts playback. This was observed on MPC-X standalone running firmware 2.13.0. To reproduce:
1) Configure a MIDI track to receive notes using MIDI DIN from an external sequencer. Make the sequence receive and use the MPC's clock, start and stop. Record a sequence made of rich chords, e.g. 5 notes at a time.
2) Set the Monitor button from Auto to Off.
3) On the external sequencer, change its configuration to play something else, but so that it still starts and stops together with the MPC.
4) Playback the sequence, and you will hear that a few notes in the chord seem to be disrupted: they don't start at all, or get a Note Off sooner than the others in the same chord. For safety, monitor what is played by using a MIDI visualizer (e.g. see https://imgur.com/eXZkxCa ).
5) Set MIDI INPUT to <none>, and the sequence will playback correctly instead.
But shouldn't the Monitor button set to off be sufficient not to be disrupted by the external sequencer? The user guide version 2.13 on page 147 says that "When set to Off, the track's MIDI input is not monitored, and playback of recorded events will be heard".



