Talk and share knowledge on rare records, sources of new samples, vinyl, diggin, etc
By C-Train Sat Apr 23, 2005 4:16 pm
minor? When i got the mpc the only thing i heard about is to get soul records. now i got a whole bunch and after messing w/ them for a while i didn't think of the fact that almost every song is in major. i think minor samples sound so much better than major imo, so which genre of music is usually in a minor key (other than classical because i have enough of that kind of music) and also more unique? i have not listened to very much older music and only listen to modern rap and jam rock so i am not too good in this area :?:

By C-Train Wed Apr 27, 2005 12:24 am
does anyone even know what a major and minor key are around here
By simcity Wed Apr 27, 2005 2:55 am
but apparently you don't because you are asking for whole genres to find minor samples.

By 2wice Wed Apr 27, 2005 6:04 am
Can't you adjust the pitch to change keys?
User avatar

By pt3r Wed Apr 27, 2005 6:31 am
My theoretical knowledge on chords is not very evolved but AFAIK you can tune whatever you want, you can not tune a sample of major chord to a minor chord.
User avatar

By Bezo Wed Apr 27, 2005 8:40 pm
Try some blues and jazz.

And a lot of soul songs are in minor keys. I can't imagine you have none that are.

Also, even songs in major keys sometimes use minor chords. Listen out for those parts.
By C-Train Thu Apr 28, 2005 4:26 am
simcity wrote:but apparently you don't because you are asking for whole genres to find minor samples.


apparently you didn't understand my question, and thank you for those who did
By simcity Thu Apr 28, 2005 5:29 am
Hebrew and Israeli music is all in minor keys.
By C-Train Sat Apr 30, 2005 12:39 am
simcity wrote:Hebrew and Israeli music is all in minor keys.


oh i didn't see that you wrote hebrew music in the title of your first post. and i thought nobody was going to reply so i had to be a smartass. sorry (doh)
User avatar

By erkl Sat Apr 30, 2005 2:12 am
i have not listened to very much older music and only listen to modern rap and jam rock so i am not too good in this area


start listening to more soul or whatever sound your going for, you gotta LISTEN to the music to hear what there is to sample...

listen while u work, walk, read, whatever - dont sleep
User avatar

By Blue Haze Sat Apr 30, 2005 12:42 pm
Don`t want to come off as harsh but doesnt mpcs have pitch and the 4k has pitch correction. If you have the ears you can change it. Think like a dj aka musician. :idea:

By C-Train Sun May 01, 2005 2:56 am
thanks for the suggestions

erkl, your avator is frightening :shock: lol

By reptilzar Thu May 05, 2005 8:01 am
yo, you can make ANY thing sound minor, even if it's a happy ass C major chord, hit the right tensions (out of key notes) underneath, like wit your bass or whatever, you can make it bang..

if you can make happy shit sound angry then you roll right, you know?


and for music.. jazz. there tons of dark jazz out there, you can get mad cheap jazz records too!
User avatar

By dubmunkey Thu May 05, 2005 2:43 pm
pitch is different to key

i think your lack of replys was just due to the question being a bit esoteric...loads of genres mix...hell a lot of jazz is based on the harmonic minor which is different on the way up than it is down...

musical genres with overtly minor leanings?

trance- not the original kind but that stadium shite that calls itself trance- like the dance equivilent of neo-classical-rock this genre loves the minor scale and simply loves big dramatic minor scale riffs and progressions- very classical sounding
dub- lots of minor chords here, not always to a scale but dub is often the dark to ska's lighter happier side...
techno- if a scale is gonna be sued it will be minor or a vraiant of- if not something weirdass...nothing major as a rule- you'll be lucky to find a scale...

i cant think of any other genres which use that scale all the time, both dnb and house love the minor scale but need to jazz it up so its not too dramatic, a lot of blues is minor based but they use blue notes and scale jumps to give that funky blue flavour...

when it comes to ethnic style there are definitly genres almost exclusivly written in a minor or minor variant...flamenco comes to mind (although think the actual scale is phyrigian mode than an aeolian)

and as someone said major is relative to minor....you could play a c major chord and then add an a at the bass to get an a minor chord....not the same as keys but the two are inextricable linked

greg