skmagnum wrote:im taking music theory rite now at Berklee online...damn its only week 3 and ive learned so much. watch my beat game step up! i think you should take it. no sense in buying all this outboard equipment and not get any mental equipment...
See, there you go! It does help. No matter if you're Mozart or Primo, music theory does affect the way musical production sounds.
I think it's a combination of natural talent and musical training. Having one without the other doesn't help anyone.
Even though musicans that play by ear don't know much theory, they still follow the rules(knowingly or not). They say these musician are more talented, but this method will catch up to them in the long run(if they wanna become serious musicians or producers).
Trained musicians know all of the rules and can manipulate their music however they'd like. They have endless resources to use when creating music. A trained musician wouldn't have to ask "How do you write a chorus or bridge for a R&B song?"
Don't get me wrong though, an untrained(and talented)producer could do that too(untrained musicians and producers have listened to countless hours of their favorite music since they were children, like myself, but I can read music. I didn't learn how until I was in the 7th grade. Music class in Oklahona is mandatory in elementary school, grades K-5 or 6. Between that and my run for my chruch choir, that's how I got all of my musical traning.)
Untrained musicians have to "feel" the music more.
Trained musicans could give the technical explanation of their own(or anyone else's)music.
Like I said it's good to have both aspects.
Buying a MPC without any one of these abilities is suicide. But it has been done.