Kapser wrote:Thanks a lot for the detailed description Metatron72!
And to the people who think it is the biggest death sin in the world to sample from something else than vinyl... well.
Im just a kid with few money, so i don't have that kind of money to go out and buy vinyls all the time..
And i do not have some long music education so i can hear the exact sound quality, and all that other things.
So for me it is fine, if i can have some fun with a little music-making at home, sampling from youtube.
And by the way, i don't know if you guys have any interest in hiphop, but party supplies have made an album called Blue Chips with Action Bronson, one of the most promising new rappers, where party supplies have produced it all. The album have received some very fine reviews, and i actually haven't heard anyone complain about the sound quality of the project, even though... yes... he samples from youtube.
I'm not a vinyl purist although truly nothing in the world sounds better. I do feel in a general sense that we should aim for the best quality possible even if a grungy sound is what we desire. A higher resolution doesn't automatically mean no grit, it's just more to work with.
In a lot of cases people will be coupling the samples with VST's or sounds from a sample library which will always be at least 16/44. If all your sounds are in that quality range it's just easier to gel them together with less chance of one element sounding thinner than the others. Also regarding volume and impendence, the higher resolution files make life easier there. You won't have to use as much gain and avoid digital clipping more easily. In my experience a lower bit rate MP3 if recorded from an original vinyl source holds up much better than a digital rip dithered to the lower compressed bit rate.
This is easy to see if you listen to golden age hip hop You Tube videos from 1988-1994 or so. Tons of these are vinyl rips and it's the best you'll ever here a 240p stream sound. I'm talking mostly hip hop records here. To me it's a combination of the character of vinyl coming through even at a low bit rate and that the drums on most of these records came out of MPC60/3000's and SP1200's the 2 basic definitions of golden age hip hop drums.
Like most things the truth of this stuff is somewhere in the middle. Sometimes an mp3 will sound full and good enough. But I can't fully co-sign the attitude the guy in the video had that no one cares about sound quality so why bother.
Sounds like you feel where I;m coming from Kasper. Just wanted to show that even with no dough the options still exist to get a good source recording.