By
lo-fi
Tue Jan 04, 2005 5:10 am
I think the sound of EXS24mkII is pretty decent, it's on a par with the rest of Logic's sound engine, which sounds pretty damn good to my ears.
HOWEVER, I can't even begin to count the ways in which the EXS24 user interface SUCKS!
It's designed for people who use sample libraries and realistic multi-sampled string sounds and stuff. It probably works great for them - you load up a ready-made patch, tweak the filter a little and play it.
But that's not what I (and most MPC users) use a sampler for. Most of us use it to quickly grab sounds from records and sequence them. This simple procedure takes AGES on EXS24, and after you've sampled a sound, saved it, selected a keygroup, and loaded the sound into it (yawn), you don't even have a full set of filter/envelope settings for each sample! You have to assign each sample to a seperate 'group' to even get a filter offset parameter per sample. The filter has a choice of HP/LP/BP, with different slopes and a 'drive' control, but these settings have to be the same for all samples in the program!!! It's ridicoulous. Oh and it uses two seperate windows (WTF?) which sometimes can't find each other's settings... Joy.
EXS wasn't designed as a 'drum-sampler' or a 'phrase sampler' but more as a sample-library-playback-device, and it's absolutely useless as a 'samplist's sampler', if that phrase makes any sense.
Oh and Scratch mag is for little kids. It has some alright interviews, but anything technical in that mag is just silly. A typical monitor review would be something like 'it sounds very nice and the bass goes down real low...' Oh, great, I'll buy those then. The whole mag is just product placement with some half-assed comments. Like it has pictures of some turntables and then it says 'these turntables come in many different colors!' Wow. It's made by a bunch of guys with no knowledge whatsoever trying to make a quick buck and it shows.
... Sorry for the rant(s)...
BTW, I haven't yet heard a softsynth that sounds better than my SE1x. What are you using?