By Logrinn
Fri Jul 19, 2024 1:37 pm
denony wrote:Hello,Logrinn wrote:I tried this just now, and I wasn't able to get this bug.
I sent a note on message (C3) on channel 1 and then a note off message (also C3) on channel 2 and the note on channel 1 keeps sounding.
So, yes, it seems fixed.
Perhaps someone else can confirm?
Did you try to record both Midi tracks in a sequence ?
I just tested, the "Multichannel Note OFF" bug still exists in 2.15 (on my MPC One)
I did not. I only sent midi messages to the synth engine (plugin) and didn't get this behavior.
So I tried what you are saying - sending several channels to the synth/plugin while recording. And this time I did encounter the bug.
Checked the list edit info, but I couldn't see any channel message info (just note and velocity value) so that didn't help me.
But as I recorded the first set of notes on track one using an external keyboard that sent on midi channel 1, I recorded the second set of notes on track two using the external keyboard now set to channel 2.
And the bug was there.
BUT - the both tracks when I tried this were using the same plugin. And when I assigned a second plugin to track two, I could hear both set of notes, from both track one and track two, and the note-off problem was no longer present.
So - in a way the bug is there, but in another way it's not. What I could gather the problem seem to be present when sending note on and note off messages for the same note number to a particular track or several tracks that are sharing the same synth/plugin.
It seems that the sequencer doesn't adhere to the basic channel messages or is set to some type of omni mode when one is recording to it from an external source. OR - from the internal keyboard as well (just tried that too although the same midi channel was used both times).
Two tracks recorded and the note off messages on track two kills the sounding notes on track one - IF the tracks share the same plugin. If they have separate plugins the problem is no longer there.
I'm using a Key 37.





