Hey no problem, it's all good. DC huh? I know a few cats there. Do you know Misha and these kids from Ish Lab? What about Sky and Northstar?
Anyway, you bring up some good questions, and it seems like you will be picking up speed quickly.
Yeah man, the chaper recorders don't have good inputs, and the trim (level boost, or 'gain' at the inputs) knobs only help so much. The guy who told you about the limits of the four track analog was sort-of-right. The problem is that it doesn't amplify that well at input, mic OR instrument levels. Also, it doesn't have alot of headroom, which is how many decibles you can pump into a device before it distorts. So your limited at both ends: it won't pickup very well, and then when you crank the trim, and just a decible or two too high, and you're distorting. Here's the thing though: There are intrument level and line level devices. A guitar needs more amplification that your MPC or say a Pro Keyboard. But once your vocal signal is inside a mic pre or processor, the device (like the tube pre) will usually output a line level signal. Then you have enough gain, but you can turn the output on the pre all the way down to nothing if it's still coming into the recorder too hard. Some 4tracks have one mic input, two instrument inputs, and a line level input, or some combo of those. Just make sure whatever you buy will handle at least two line level inputsl. If the salesman doesn't know, than ask someone else, or read the manual a bit. You sould be all good with a tube pre and a 4track. However, check out the line level thing. Also, you can buy a cheap and effective dbx compressor on ebay for next to nothing. Do not get the model with the one slider on the front. Get one with independant knob controls, so you can learn how to use a real compressor. But I urge you to get at least some kind of compressor for recording the vocals. Just a touch will really improve the signal, and again, keep it in line as far as gain at the recorder input stage. Also, if you get a cheap 2 channel compressor, you can use one side for vocals. Then, when you record the whole mix to tape or CD, you can bless the whole mix with just a touch of compression. It will make it pump a little warmer, and smooth it out a bit as well. The two channel units link left and right together, so you can put a stereo mix through it and one sides controls effect both channels. More on this later when you get there. I will look up good recomendations for cost effective compressors. Try
www.sweetwater.com. You can even call them, tell them what you want to do and your price range. They are really good and won't try to upsell you that much.
Ok, 4track vs. Digital again. Yeah the VS-880 or an 8track fostex digital will do you much better than the analog four track. These units have ok digital compressors for use during mixing, which is great. Another reason
I'd recomend the VS-880. However, they don't have input compressors. You could concievably route through the compressor effects, and onto a new track you are recording on, but it's more hassle than it's worth. An analog compressor is better for tracking anyway, You may have to save a little more, but I feel it's worth it. See what kind of deal you can get, then get the 4 track if you can't wait any longer to get the price you want. And yes, the VS880 or similar priced model has much more headroom than an analog 4 track.
The split-side recording protocall was invented for analog, but some have applied the idea to digital. Whereas in my old digital 4 track minidisk, I could choose any input, and select L or R. If it was oin channel 3, and I chose R, it would actually record on channel 4. Weird. This happens because a channel is actually one stereo input with two faders, then you route it. I see cats using a y-cable (two mono out the MPC, to a single stereo) plugged into a mono channel on thier recorder, or vice-versa when they are sampling. This is a no-no. What that does is carry the stereo signal to the recorder, but your plugged into a mono jack, so it doesn't have a pickup for both sides of the stereo plug. Usually it will just grab the left side of the signal.
All you need to know is, even if all your samples coming out the MPC are mono, there are comming out on two jacks. Now your pumping out dual-mono. If you only jack one side into the recorder, your losing haldf the signal. Stereo is gonna lose volume and it's whole other side of the 'image', and dual mono is gonna half itself in volume as well. So, if you want to record in mono, pan all samples in the MPC mixer screen to the side of the output you are using. out of the sampler. You will not have to worry about this with the VS880. Usually, when you go to 8 tracks digital, you don't have to pan at input. They have what are called 'discreet' channels. That means they exist entirely as their own channel.
I think in your situation you are right to want to skip the computer. The power you will get out of VS880 will be fine for now. With a computer, you can do more intense graphic editing, like put in 4 bars of a song from the MPC, then loop in the computer to save recording space. But if you get nice on the VS, you can do all that too, it just takes longer. And then you won't have to worry about configuring anything, you'll just be recording. With a really slow computer, you may be in for a dissapointment. It's up to you.
If you get the gear you listed here, you would be set. If you use the digital effects that come with these recorders tastefully, you can do alot. The stuff on your list is a complete basic package, and should make you very happy. Keep me posted, and I will send you some links for gear shopping.
Peace