By
trupro
Fri Mar 19, 2004 6:27 pm
Wow. This cat is serious. Violenty serious. No really, man, he's right about the MPC. I know that, when I used outside studios, before I had gear, I liked other ish than the MPC, cus I thought it made a different signature for me. You know what? I was right, but only 50%.
That is, while what you use does effect your sound, you won't necessarily sound like other people when you use an MPC, or specific piece of gear.
The thing is, if you want to learn the theory of professional sequencing, sampling, midi, etc, an all in one unit is great. And, like we all know, the MPC is great for that. Now, I want to go against that sales dude YET AGAIN. Everykeyboard sequencer I have used pales in comparison to the MPC. COmputers are better, but sometimes, there are so many options in your grill for the midi, that it actually detracts from what you are doing. I feel keyboard sequencers suck because they attempt to incorporate this 'workstation' approach where you have to process data to record internal sequences (Roland, and ASR line) OR, they are limited in what you can do from one screen (Roland, Triton, Yamahas,).
However, if you are set on a keyboard, concentrate on it's useability, NOT IT'S SOUNDS. Sure, it has to have some good sounds to start. However, you can expand almost all of the keyboards out there, and, if you can learn the architecture of the box intuitively, then you can always edit and save to make new sounds. User friendliness is the most important thing in a computer, and these pieces of gear ARE computers with graphic user interfaces (GUIs). The MPC 2000 and 2000XL are actually not that feature-packed, compared to similar products, but it's GUI is so intuitive that you concentrate on making music, not on buttons, bells and whistles. So, while many other machines can POTENTIALLY do more, they fall by the wayside for lack of fluent access to those features.
The most important thing, I believe, is to have an impartial party to help you shop. A sales guy, no matter how nice, has a certain product to push that month, especially if he is part of a major chain store (sam ash, guitar center, etc.) It's best to get with someone who has two or three of the keyboards you desire, AND an MPC, and let them show you the strengths and weaknesses of all of them. Then, you can make an informed decision, having used the gear already. I think it is CRUCIAL that you make at least one multitrack composition on as many pieces as possible, before you spend money. If not, you may find yourself bringing equipment back to the store. And, god forbid, your cat pees in the disk drive and you get stuck with that cat-piss keyboard. Didn't happen to me. I hate cats. But seriously, make an informed decision.