MPC5000 reviews, bug reports and fellow user support on the most recent standalone, hardware MPC from Akai
By Sammy Farr Thu Aug 07, 2008 3:12 am
I recently got my hands on an mpc5000 for some work and i need it to be synced perfectly with pro tools. ive tried midi time code and beat clock, but when i record the mpc's click into tools it isn't lined up perfectly with the grid. its only a little bit out (about a quarter to half a frame) but its still not good enough. ive tred both the mpc and pro tools as master with similar results. some times the click is consistently late, sometimes its a bit early and sometimes the click isn't consistent at all, one beat might be a bit early and the next a bit late. ive even tried loading a track of smpte time code on to the mpc and had tools chase it which still isnt perfect. is this the "mpc groove" people talk about or am i missing something? i am new to the world of mpc's but have been working with pro tools professionally for years and would really like to incorporate the mpc into my work but with these results it just isnt possible.

So my question is, has anyone recorded the mpc click into pro tools or any other daw and had it land in EXACTLY the right spot? man, i hope so. i might have to get the akai pad controller otherwise...

thanks in advance

Sam
By tomazzzi Thu Aug 07, 2008 7:00 am
but when i record the mpc's click into tools it isn't lined up perfectly with the grid. its only a little bit out (about a quarter to half a frame) but its still not good enough. ive tred both the mpc and pro tools as master with similar results. some times the click is consistently late, sometimes its a bit early and sometimes the click isn't consistent at all, one beat might be a bit early and the next a bit late. ive even tried loading a track of smpte time code on to the mpc and had tools chase it which still isnt perfect. is this the "mpc groove" people talk about or am i missing something? i am new to the world of mpc's but have been working with pro tools professionally for years and would really like to incorporate the mpc into my work but with these results it just isnt possible.

So my question is, has anyone recorded the mpc click into pro tools or any other daw and had it land in EXACTLY the right spot? man, i hope so. i might have to get the akai pad controller otherwise...



Sound like a latency problem ...

What sound card do you use ?

what midi interface do you use ?

You ll always get a little latency while recording the MPC to your DAW, it s nearly impossible to get it perfectly lined up to the grid.

Though with a good sound card you might only have about 3ms of latency, not more, so it s easy to compensate it.

Check your buffer setting on the sound card & make sure your using the lowest possible.
Last edited by tomazzzi on Fri Aug 08, 2008 5:28 pm, edited 1 time in total.
By Sammy Farr Thu Aug 07, 2008 7:40 pm
Thanks but its not a latency issue, im using pthd 7 a 192 i/o, an emagic unitor and a sync i/o.

I know the mpc 2000xl had built in smpte in and out - did anyone use this successfully?
User avatar
By nyahmusic Fri Aug 08, 2008 4:17 pm
Even when using MIDI Beat Clock, after the first two bars, it should lock up well.

If its not locked up to the grid at that point, it is a latency issue. Lower the buffer size on your sound card to a low as possible (without causing crackles). In most circumstances, a setting of 64 or 128 samples should get things as tight as possible.

Even the best cards have 1.5ms of min latency this will always translate into a delay. If you are noticing a difference of 3 or fewer frames, then its nothing to worry about.

Hope that this helps!
By tomazzzi Fri Aug 08, 2008 5:28 pm
Thanks but its not a latency issue, im using pthd 7 a 192 i/o, an emagic unitor and a sync i/o.


No matter what you use it can be a latency issue if not properly configured.

I v no pb at all with Logic Studio & Ableton Live the sync is perfect.

Motu 828mk2, Presonus Firestation, Edirol UM3EX

Buffer 128
By Sammy Farr Wed Aug 13, 2008 1:14 am
tomazzzi wrote:
Thanks but its not a latency issue, im using pthd 7 a 192 i/o, an emagic unitor and a sync i/o.


No matter what you use it can be a latency issue if not properly configured.

I v no pb at all with Logic Studio & Ableton Live the sync is perfect.

Motu 828mk2, Presonus Firestation, Edirol UM3EX

Buffer 128


thanks tomazzi. the system is definitely configured correctly. Have you tried to record the mpc's click into logic and found it to be exactly in time? im finding it is only out a little bit (still tighter than a real drummer) but i would love for it to be perfect if possible.

Cheers

Sam
By tomazzzi Wed Aug 13, 2008 7:11 am
There s always a little latency, i don t know any card with 0 latency.

You can compensate it by using audio delay on your audio tracks or vti tracks then everything will be in perfect sync.

Then, when the recording is done, you only have to remove the delay on the tracks & move the audio of your recorded tracks to make it fit perfectly to the grid.

Hope this helps
User avatar

By Lampdog Wed Aug 13, 2008 7:22 am
tomazzzi wrote:There s always a little latency, i don t know any card with 0 latency.

You can compensate it by using audio delay on your audio tracks or vti tracks then everything will be in perfect sync.

Then, when the recording is done, you only have to remove the delay on the tracks & move the audio of your recorded tracks to make it fit perfectly to the grid.

Hope this helps


That sums up everything thing I've ever tried also.
User avatar
By That-1-DJ Wed Aug 13, 2008 4:35 pm
I used to have a similar problem, Then I realized that having BUS/AUX tracks only make the routing chain longer therefore creating more latency. When I removed the BUS/AUX tracks I noticed a HUGE difference, I always insert 2 empty measures into the MPC. eg. grab a seq. that contains all of the voices/tracks that I want to use for the song, Bring up that seq. in song mode and start by solo'ing the first track, Go back to the main page and goto an empty seq. set it up for 2 bars, and make sure that the tempo is the same as your song will be. In SONG MODE insert the empty seq. 1st and then your main seq. 2nd. and record them into Pro Tools, If you have a song that consist of the basic 4 measures you will be recording at least 6 measures in Pro Tools (((2 measures = Empty seq.) + (4 measures = actual song seq.) = (6 measures TOTAL))) once you have all of your tracks entered int Pro Tools, Highlight all tracks and cut and delete the first 2 measures, Bring the song to the starting point and set your loop and you should have a perfect loop. and from there CREATE YOUR SONG!
After you create your song you can add BUS/AUX tracks if you wish, for your MIXDOWN.

I know it might sound confusing, but it is really simple works like a charm for me.

at the beginning the sync is off just by a hair, That is why I put 2 empty measures to allow it time to sync up PERFECTLY!

Hope this helps!
User avatar
By itslikezacanduh Wed Aug 13, 2008 5:28 pm
tomazzzi wrote:There s always a little latency, i don t know any card with 0 latency.

You can compensate it by using audio delay on your audio tracks or vti tracks then everything will be in perfect sync.

Then, when the recording is done, you only have to remove the delay on the tracks & move the audio of your recorded tracks to make it fit perfectly to the grid.

Hope this helps


Wow. So that's how you do it. Thanks!
By Sammy Farr Sun Aug 17, 2008 4:42 am
That-1-DJ wrote:I used to have a similar problem, Then I realized that having BUS/AUX tracks only make the routing chain longer therefore creating more latency. When I removed the BUS/AUX tracks I noticed a HUGE difference, I always insert 2 empty measures into the MPC. eg. grab a seq. that contains all of the voices/tracks that I want to use for the song, Bring up that seq. in song mode and start by solo'ing the first track, Go back to the main page and goto an empty seq. set it up for 2 bars, and make sure that the tempo is the same as your song will be. In SONG MODE insert the empty seq. 1st and then your main seq. 2nd. and record them into Pro Tools, If you have a song that consist of the basic 4 measures you will be recording at least 6 measures in Pro Tools (((2 measures = Empty seq.) + (4 measures = actual song seq.) = (6 measures TOTAL))) once you have all of your tracks entered int Pro Tools, Highlight all tracks and cut and delete the first 2 measures, Bring the song to the starting point and set your loop and you should have a perfect loop. and from there CREATE YOUR SONG!
After you create your song you can add BUS/AUX tracks if you wish, for your MIXDOWN.

I know it might sound confusing, but it is really simple works like a charm for me.

at the beginning the sync is off just by a hair, That is why I put 2 empty measures to allow it time to sync up PERFECTLY!

Hope this helps!


Thanks mate, ill give it a go later this week. all my tests came up with the same results. The mpc's timing isn't perfect, it wobbles about a bit. its more likely that its just that midi in general isnt perfect. beat detective will fix it